The family of a paranoid schizophrenic wanted to get psychiatric help for him in the weeks before he killed his parents with an axe, the Central Criminal Court has heard.
Julian Cuddihy (43), has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity to the murder of his parents Kathleen (73), and James (77), at their family home in Churchtown, Carndonagh, Co Donegal on October 22nd, 2014.
Det Garda Bernard Mullins of Buncrana Garda station told prosecuting counsel Denis Vaughan Buckley SC that Julian Cuddihy’s father cancelled an appointment with local mental health services six days before the violent episode that left him and his wife dead.
Consultant psychiatrist Dr Damian Mohan gave further evidence that Julian’s parents were concerned over the stigma associated with mental health.
Speaking to defence counsel Brendan Grehan SC, he said Ms Cuddihy in particular did not want her son to be committed and worried he would resent his parents if they had him hospitalised against his will.
At that time Julian Cuddihy was refusing to eat because he believed his mother was trying to poison him.
Stealing his thoughts
He could not sleep because he worried people were stealing his thoughts while he slept and he believed he could prevent aliens from reading his mind if he joined the IRA.
He had become convinced that people were conspiring against him and had taken to sleeping in an annexe attached to the family home with an axe for protection.
His symptoms had been building for several years and in December of the previous year the family met their general practitioner to discuss the possibility of having him committed but, Dr Mohan said, the decision was deferred.
By October 2014 his behaviour was so erratic that his siblings felt he needed immediate psychiatric help, but his parents resisted enforced committal to a psychiatric unit.
Dr Mohan said the parents shared their family’s concerns but “did not want to follow through. They wanted to be protective of their son but also did not want him to be submitted to a mental health facility.”
Dr Mohan said the family is extremely unified and loving and only ever wanted what was best for Julian, but he added that mental illness is treatable with early intervention.
“Hindsight is a fine thing,” he said, adding that Mr Cuddihy has made strong progress since being committed to the Central Mental Hospital following the attack on his parents.
Detailing the nature of Mr Cuddihy’s delusions, he said he spoke to him about what he had believed in the days and weeks leading up to the attack.
He said Mr Cuddihy had heard voices telling him what to do and believed he was going to be taken away by aliens to the Matrix, referring to the Keanu Reeves film in which reality is simulated by a computer.
He said his thoughts were confused and hard to piece together. He sometimes believed his mother could read his thoughts and at other times that birds could steal his thoughts.
He had notions the IRA was trying to recruit him and this somehow tied in with the idea that aliens were reading his mind and that he was going to be taken to the Matrix.
Conspiring against him
His paranoia led him to believe people were conspiring against him and that his mother was trying to poison him.
Two nights before the killing he had stayed out in one of the fields near their home, believing aliens were going to take him away to another dimension.
He waited all night and was “greatly disappointed when the spaceship did not arrive”.
On the night of the killing he said his mother had told him to eat his dinner and he then heard her voice in his head. She told him: “I want you to kill me and your father.”
He believed that by killing them he was sending them to heaven, and when he attacked them with the axe he thought he was following his mother’s commands.
Later that night, as he wandered through fields near the family home, he became convinced he was in the Matrix, an alternative reality, and that he therefore had not really killed his parents.
Det Garda Mullins had earlier confirmed details from State Pathologist Prof Marie Cassidy’s report into the deaths of Kathleen and James Cuddihy.
Prof Cassidy described multiple wounds to the head consistent with blows from an axe that caused severe head trauma. She also discovered stab wounds to James’s neck, chest and face that she believed could have been caused by a pair of scissors found close to his body.
She said he had suffered multiple chop wounds to the head in quick succession.
Ms Cuddihy had suffered at least seven blows to the head, some of which she believed were inflicted while she was lying down unconscious or possibly already dead.
Garda Mullins recalled an interview with Mr Cuddihy jnr at Buncrana Garda station on October 24th, two days after the double killing.
Speaking to counsel for the prosecution, Denis Vaughan Buckley SC, he said that during the interview gardaí had asked Mr Cuddihy if he knew what would happen when he struck his parents with the axe.
He responded: “I believed their lives were going to pass on to the unifying field. I knew they were going to die. When the switch turned on I knew they were going to die,” he said, adding that he did it “as quickly and painlessly as possible”.
The trial continues on Thursday in front of Justice Margaret Heneghan and a jury of seven women and five men.