Officials at the Solomon R Guggenheim Museum in New York were tight-lipped Thursday night about an unusual email exchange in which its chief curator is said to have rebuffed a White House request for a Vincent van Gogh painting and offered a gold toilet instead.
The exchange between the curator, Nancy Spector, and Donna Hayashi Smith of the White House's Office of the Curator was reported Thursday afternoon by The Washington Post.
Citing a September 15th email the Post said it had obtained, the newspaper reported that Spector had turned down the White House's request to borrow van Gogh's Landscape with Snow, which officials had hoped they could use to decorate President Donald and Melania Trump's living quarters.
As an alternative, the Post said Spector offered up what one might call a "participatory sculpture": a fully functional, 18-carat-gold copy of a Kohler toilet titled "America" that more than 100,000 people had already used in a museum restroom.
"It is, of course, extremely valuable and somewhat fragile, but we would provide all the instructions for its installation and care," the Post quoted Spector as writing in the email to the White House curator's office. The sculpture's artist, the email said, "would like to offer it to the White House for a long-term loan".
Asked Thursday night if she could confirm the Post's report, Sarah Eaton, a spokeswoman for the Guggenheim, said only, "I have nothing further to add." Eaton would not make the email described by the Post available to the New York Times and said Spector was not available for comment.
Attempts to reach Spector; Richard Armstrong, the Guggenheim’s director; and the sculpture’s artist, Maurizio Cattelan, were not successful.
It was not clear if Spector would face discipline. (The Guggenheim rehired her from the Brooklyn Museum last year in a new and more powerful position.)
The Times also sent emails to multiple White House spokespeople who did not immediately respond to requests for comment Thursday night.
Although most of the sculptures and historical objects on display in the White House are part of its permanent art collection, when a new first family arrives, the curator’s office selects pieces to display in the building’s public and private spaces.
Presidents and their families have full veto authority, however, and most have exercised it when seeking to add their own touches.
President Ronald Reagan insisted that a portrait of Calvin Coolidge hang in the Cabinet room; President George W Bush displayed in the Oval Office a painting by WHD Koerner, which showed a cowboy racing a horse up a mountain trail; and President Barack Obama added two Edward Hopper paintings, which he got on a loan from the Whitney Museum of American Art.
The Obamas, experts and historians have said, demonstrated a penchant for modern and contemporary art.
The “America” work could also be labeled such. In a blog post Spector wrote about the piece last year, she called it “at once humorous and searing in its critique of our current realities”.
“Though crafted from millions of dollars’ worth of gold, the sculpture is actually a great leveler,” she continued, adding that “Cattelan’s anticipation of Trump’s America will, perhaps, be the lasting imprint of the sculpture’s time at the Guggenheim.” (The sculpture’s exact cost has not been revealed.)
Another blog post on the Guggenheim website said that “while Cattelan agrees that he could hardly have known about the rise of Trump when he conceived of the piece”, he has said “it was probably in the air”.
In explaining the piece, Cattelan has noted, “Whatever you eat, a $200 lunch or a $2 hot dog, the results are the same, toilet-wise.” – New York Times
