Paramilitaries in North ‘used fear to sexually exploit children’

Known cases are tip of the iceberg said people consulted by inquiry into abuse

The report recommends police establish better links with young people. Photograph: Dara Mac Dónaill
The report recommends police establish better links with young people. Photograph: Dara Mac Dónaill

Paramilitaries in Northern Ireland used their fearsome reputations to sexually exploit children, according to a report.

Powerful individuals connected to the organisations held after hours “lock-ins” at pubs where the practice occurred.

Fear for their lives stopped some victims identifying perpetrators, according to accounts obtained by an independent inquiry.

"They were described as people to whom you cannot say no," said Stormont Minister for Health Jim Wells. "They regard themselves as beyond the law."

READ MORE

Soldiers have also been disciplined for smuggling girls into two different barracks within the last three years, report author Kathleen Marshall said. This is included in a range of abuses of power detailed dating to the armed conflict.

Her review estimated between 100 and 145 children are at significant risk of exploitation but most people consulted by the inquiry said what is known is likely to be the tip of the iceberg.

“Child sexual exploitation is not new, but it has become a more significant threat to a greater number of children and young people with ready access to the internet,” said Prof Marshall. “While it is difficult to assess the extent of child sexual exploitation, the indications are that it is widespread and growing. It is not restricted to children in care.”

Although many consulted in the report said Northern Ireland was not experiencing the sort of organised exploitation seen in Rochdale or Rotherham, the inquiry predicted that more cases would be identified.

Prof Marshall, former children's commissioner in Scotland, has spent a year examining the extent of the problem in the North. She was appointed by Stormont's Minister for Health.

It followed the arrest of more than 30 people in a major Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) investigation last year.

Exploitation can include party houses where drugs or alcohol may be provided “free” but young people are expected to pay for it with sex.

It can be a relationship which begins consensually but can develop into sexual activity with the partner’s friends and associates.

It can involve transportation from place to place and money may change hands. Increasingly children, mainly girls, can be exploited through the internet and social media, sharing of indecent images and using them for blackmail, the report said.

The inquiry consulted 580 young people and 795 parents.

The police view is that organised paramilitary involvement in child sexual exploitation has not been established.

The Marshall Inquiry noted the involvement of powerful people with purported links to paramilitary organisations, even though exploitation was not a targeted activity of those groups.

“It was a case of individuals using the authority of their paramilitary links and the fear it engendered to exploit children and young people.”

The inquiry also heard of cases involving army members, in the past and in recent times.

“The cases in the past related to alleged actions by the security forces during the Troubles and were described to us as part of a whole spectrum of abuse of power.

“Those who spoke to us recounted movingly the impact this had had on their lives.”

More recently two separate incidents involving different barracks saw girls smuggled inside and sexual activity taking place.

The investigations led to disciplinary procedures in relation to some army personnel, and tightened security at the barracks to prevent further unauthorised entry.

“The information we received from the health and social care trusts indicates that the army is responsive to concerns and engages in collaborative working,” the report said.

“The Ministry of Defence confirmed that they take allegations of this nature extremely seriously and work closely with PSNI to ensure that allegations are dealt with thoroughly, and as promptly as possible.”

Often young people do not see themselves as victims in these cases and may come from difficult backgrounds where they do not have a close adult figure to look after them, Prof Marshall said.

In one case a girl advertised for a lift on social media in exchange for a sex act.

Children as young as nine or 10 have viewed pornography, some have tried to act it out.

“Young people’s views about what is normal are affected by this and other messages from the media,” the report said. “This has helped shape . . . a new normality among young people, involving an expectation of multiple sexual partners and sexual activity in circumstances where the existence of consent is often questionable.”

“There are few prosecutions and convictions for sexual offences against children and this exacerbates the reluctance to report and to engage.”

The report said there should be a joined up and strategic approach.

It made 17 key recommendations. These included: a public health campaign on child exploitation; police prioritising stronger relations with young people; more guidance for parents and carers on obtaining information when a child is considered at risk and changes to criminal justice that could achieve more successful prosecutions. PA