Europe

‘No grounds’ for lifting Russia sanctions

Sanctions in place against Russia over alleged support for pro-Moscow rebels in Ukraine

Local people hold a placard with the words ‘Volnovakha’, during their march in memory of the victims of a civilian bus shelling in eastern Ukraine in the Volnovakha city, Ukraine. In the worst incident in recent months, 12 civilians were killed and 18 injured when an artillery shell hit a bus in the eastern Donetsk region on 13 January, local authorities said. The bus was standing at a Ukrainian army checkpoint near the town of Volnovakha when it was hit by a shell fired from pro-Russian separatists, the Kiev-loyal regional government said in a statement. Photograph: Alexander Ermoochenko/EPA
Local people hold a placard with the words ‘Volnovakha’, during their march in memory of the victims of a civilian bus shelling in eastern Ukraine in the Volnovakha city, Ukraine. In the worst incident in recent months, 12 civilians were killed and 18 injured when an artillery shell hit a bus in the eastern Donetsk region on 13 January, local authorities said. The bus was standing at a Ukrainian army checkpoint near the town of Volnovakha when it was hit by a shell fired from pro-Russian separatists, the Kiev-loyal regional government said in a statement. Photograph: Alexander Ermoochenko/EPA
Mon Jan 19 2015 - 12:01

European Union foreign ministers said on Monday there were no grounds to lift economic sanctions against Russia despite conciliatory proposals from the EU's foreign policy chief as violence intensified in eastern Ukraine.

Federica Mogherini had suggested in a confidential memo seen by Reuters that member states could start talking to Russia again about global diplomacy, trade and other issues if Moscow implemented agreements to end the separatist conflict in neighbouring Ukraine.

“I don’t think that we now should think how to re-engage. Russia should think how to re-engage,“ Lithuanian foreign minister Linas Linkevicius told reporters as he arrived for a meeting where Ms Mogherini’s paper was to be discussed.

An armoured personal carrier (APC) of Ukrainian forces patrols the street of Volnovakha city. Photograph: Alexander Ermoochenko/EPA
An armoured personal carrier (APC) of Ukrainian forces patrols the street of Volnovakha city. Photograph: Alexander Ermoochenko/EPA

Ms Mogherini’s suggestion has gone down badly with some of the EU‘s more hawkish states, such as Lithuania, which suggested it would send the wrong message to Russian President Vladimir Putin that the EU‘s resolve was cracking.

READ MORE

The EU has joined the United States in imposing tough sanctions on Russia over its alleged support for the pro-Moscow rebels in Ukraine but the bloc’s 28 member states are divided in their enthusiasm for sanctions.

Ms Linkevicius said there was no reason to change the EU‘s policy or to lift sanctions.

With attempts to restart peace talks stalled, rebels have stepped up attacks in the past week and casualties have mounted. Fighting has raged around Donetsk airport.

Danish foreign minister Martin Lidegaard said the time was not right for the EU to “give up any sanctions or to send any signals that we are willing to do so, but ... we should explore any possibility to find a political solution to this crisis.“

Swedish foreign minister Margot Wallstrom said the EU must hold on to its sanctions on Russia, but it also needed a long-term perspective on engaging with Moscow.

Mr Mogherini said any relaxation of sanctions on Russia would only happen if there were improvements on the ground in Ukraine.

Sebastian Kurz, foreign minister of Austria, on the doveish side of the sanctions debate, said the EU should draw up a strategy to put relations with Russia back on a firm footing in the long term. “It‘s not about sharpening or easing sanctions, it‘s about coming away from pure reaction ... I think it‘s false only to be reactive,“ he told reporters.

The first sanctions the EU imposed on Russia come up for renewal in March and unanimity is needed to extend them, which may mean more political disputes ahead.

The UN estimates that more than 4,700 people have been killed in eastern Ukraine since April.

Reuters