Ireland vs Italy head-to-head: Stuart McCloskey v Tommaso Menoncello

McCloskey’s challenge is to continue to do what he’s good at and get better in other areas, while Menoncello has all the qualities to become a generational talent for Italy

Italy's Tommaso Menoncello scores a try against Ireland at the Aviva Stadium last August. Photograph: Bryan Keane/Inpho
Italy's Tommaso Menoncello scores a try against Ireland at the Aviva Stadium last August. Photograph: Bryan Keane/Inpho
Stuart McCloskey
Ireland’s Stuart McCloskey has made incremental improvements in his game, his passing especially. Photograph: Billy Stickland/Inpho
Ireland’s Stuart McCloskey has made incremental improvements in his game, his passing especially. Photograph: Billy Stickland/Inpho

Club: Ulster

Position: Centre

Age: 31

Height: 6′4″

READ MORE

Weight: 112kg (17st 7lb)

Ireland caps: 15

Points: 20

Why he is so important? Injuries are commonplace in professional sport and for teams to be able to continue to thrive it’s important that players are able to step up when circumstances dictate. The Ulster centre performed that role admirably when playing 57 minutes against Scotland in the World Cup. This is another opportunity. He’s made incremental improvements in his game, his passing especially, and the challenge is to continue to do what he’s good at and get better in other areas. He’ll hopefully get a chance to showcase his strengths. Running a trail-line off him invariably has material benefits for team-mates.

Trivia: He played off a three handicap in golf as a teenager, his sport of preference and it wasn’t until he went to Bangor Grammar School and enjoyed a growth spurt that rugby came on his sporting radar. He recalled: “I was quite small. I played nine [scrumhalf] in my first year of the senior rugby [cycle] and I played 10 [outhalf] pushing towards centre for the last two years of senior rugby.” He is a big NBA and Lakers fan.

Tommaso Menoncello
Italy's Tommaso Menoncello playing Ireland at the Aviva Stadium. Photograph: Evan Treacy/Inpho
Italy's Tommaso Menoncello playing Ireland at the Aviva Stadium. Photograph: Evan Treacy/Inpho

Club: Benetton Treviso

Position: Centre

Age: 21

Height: 6ft2in

Weight: 101 kg (15st 12lb)

Italy caps: 13

Points: 25

Why he is so important? Quite apart from that which is apparent to the naked eye in terms of his talent, in the 2023 Six Nations he was just one of five players to play a minimum of 240 minutes who managed gain-line success and dominant carry rates of more than 50 per cent. His team-mate Juan Ignacio Brex and midfield partners Huw Jones (Scotland), Yoram Moefana (France) and George North (Wales) were the others. He has all the qualities to be a generational player for Italy.

Trivia: Menoncello became the youngest try-scorer in the history of the Six Nations when he dotted down against France on his debut in 2022. The young Treviso centre was 19 years and 170 days at the time, eclipsing the previous record held by Scotland fullback Stuart Hogg (19 years, 251 days). There were a couple of other teenagers on the list, Wales wing George North (19 years, 302 days) and France centre Gael Fickou (19 years, 317 days). The record in the Five Nations belongs to Wales fullback Keith Jarrett who was 18 when he scored his first try at Test level.

John O'Sullivan

John O'Sullivan

John O'Sullivan is an Irish Times sports writer