Top Republicans express concern after US orders withdrawal of 5,000 troops from Germany

Donald Trump reacts to criticism by German chancellor Merz of US war in Iran

German chancellor Friedrich Merz and Donald Trump at the White House in March. Photograph: Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/Getty
German chancellor Friedrich Merz and Donald Trump at the White House in March. Photograph: Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/Getty

The US has ordered the withdrawal of roughly 5,000 troops from Germany, following Donald Trump’s threats to reduce the American military presence in the country, as tensions escalate over the war with Iran.

Pentagon spokesman Sean Parnell said in a statement on Friday that defence secretary Pete Hegseth had ordered the withdrawal.

“This decision follows a thorough review of the department’s force posture in Europe and is in recognition of theatre requirements and conditions on the ground,” Parnell said.

“We expect the withdrawal to be completed over the next six to 12 months.”

Parnell did not respond to specific questions about whether the personnel would be repositioned elsewhere in Europe.

Responding to the Pentagon move, German defence minister Boris Pistorius said: “It was foreseeable that the US would withdraw troops from Europe, including Germany.”

He said that Europeans must take greater responsibility for their own security, and that Germany was “on the right track” in this regard.

The US plans were first reported earlier Friday by CBS News, which cited senior defence officials it did not name. Those officials cast the move as a demonstration of the US president’s frustration with European allies who have baulked at his calls to do more to assist the US and Israel in their war on Iran, the report said.

Two top Republican lawmakers expressed concern on Saturday ‌about the Pentagon’s decision to withdraw 5,000 troops from Nato ally Germany.

“We are very concerned by the decision to withdraw a US brigade from ​Germany,” US senator Roger Wicker and US representative Mike Rogers said in a joint statement.

Wicker, a Republican elected from Mississippi, and Rogers, from Alabama, chair ​the Senate and House Armed Services Committees, respectively.

Wicker ​and Rogers said that any significant change to the US military’s presence in Europe must be reviewed and co-ordinated with Congress and US allies.

“We expect the Department to engage with its oversight committees in the days and weeks ahead on this decision and its implications for US deterrence ‌and transatlantic security,” they ⁠said in the statement.

Even if Nato allies raised defence spending to 5 per cent of GDP, building the capabilities to ‌take over conventional deterrence will take time, and prematurely cutting US forces in ​Europe “risks undermining deterrence and sending the wrong ​signal to [Russian president] Vladimir Putin,” they said in the statement.

Earlier, Nato spokeswoman Allison Hart said the defence alliance was “working with the US to ⁠understand the details of their decision”.

“This adjustment underscores the need for ⁠Europe ​to continue to ​invest more in defence and take ‌on a greater share ​of the responsibility for our shared ⁠security – where ⁠we’re ​already seeing progress since Allies agreed to invest 5 per cent of GDP at the Nato Summit in The Hague last year.

“We ‌remain confident in ⁠our ability to provide for our deterrence and defence as ‌this shift towards a stronger Europe in ​a stronger NATO continues.”

Trump on Wednesday had said he was reviewing troop levels in Germany with an eye toward reducing those numbers. That announcement came just days after German chancellor Friedrich Merz questioned Trump’s handling of the Iran war in unusually blunt terms, saying the administration was being “humiliated”.

About 35,000 troops – almost half the total of US forces in Europe – are stationed in Germany, where the US command for the region is headquartered. The US has relied heavily on its extensive network of bases and other facilities in Germany, a legacy of the Cold War, to prepare and launch operations against Iran.

Trump’s order is likely to face opposition in Congress. His last attempt to remove forces from Germany in 2020 was blocked by legislative opposition.

Senator Jack Reed of Rhode Island, the top Democrat on the armed services committee, said in a statement that Trump “should immediately reverse this foolish decision”.

“Withdrawing thousands of American troops from one of our most important strategic positions in the middle of a war is a serious mistake that will reverberate well beyond this moment.”

The move is Trump’s latest challenge to the Nato alliance, whose other members he has long accused of not doing enough to pay for their own defence. More recently, he threatened to take Greenland from alliance partner Denmark and criticised allies for not doing more to help in the Iran campaign.

Earlier this week, Germany’s Merz questioned how Trump planned to end the conflict. “The Americans obviously have no strategy,” Merz said.

Trump then took to Truth Social, his social media site, to vent.

“The United States is studying and reviewing the possible reduction of Troops in Germany, with a determination to be made over the next short period of time,” he wrote on Thursday.

Later, he added: “The Chancellor of Germany should spend more time on ending the war with Russia/Ukraine (Where he has been totally ineffective!), and fixing his broken Country, especially Immigration and Energy, and less time on interfering with those that are getting rid of the Iran Nuclear threat, thereby making the World, including Germany, a safer place!”

On Friday, while announcing the troops decision, a senior Pentagon official said that Germany’s failure to contribute to the Iran war effort had frustrated the United States, and that the country’s rhetoric was inappropriate and unhelpful.

The announcement, and the criticism of Germany, represents a shift for Pentagon officials, who recently had praised Germany’s efforts to increase military spending and take over more of the burden of supporting Ukraine.

German foreign minister Johann Wadephul had played down Trump’s earlier warning, saying on Thursday that his government would take a “calm” look at the possibility of reducing US forces.

“The US needs these bases,” he said, citing the key facilities of Ramstein, Landstuhl and Grafenwohr.

Germany provides land for the bases rent-free, as well as staff to support the American forces.

Even if the Pentagon pulls 5,000 troops out of Germany, the country would still host the second-largest US troop presence in the world, at more than 30,000, behind only Japan. – The New York Times and agencies

  • Understand world events with Denis Staunton's Global Briefing newsletter

  • Join The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date

  • Listen to In The News podcast daily for a deep dive on the stories that matter