Two members of Scouting Ireland’s board have claimed the “integrity” of child protection standards in the youth organisation is in “jeopardy” due to infighting among directors.
They allege they raised concerns that a report about the “handling of a paedophile” had not been appropriately investigated by the organisation.
The directors, Donnachadha Reynolds and Jacques Kinane, claim the board of Scouting Ireland was beset by “terrible infighting” over the past 18 months. A document written by the pair states “the integrity of safeguarding and decisions reached in our organisation is now in jeopardy”.
The document dated November 7th last, seen by The Irish Times, reveals a rift within the board of the organisation, which in recent years has weathered a major historical child sex abuse scandal and a previous boardroom fallout.
The two board members also said they had raised concerns about the organisation’s finances due to fears the large number of legal cases taken by abuse survivors could lead to a possible “wipeout”. Mr Reynolds and Mr Kinane, who joined the voluntary board in September 2022, claimed colleagues had been “limiting” information provided to a group of three directors.
Scouting Ireland said the claims made in the document were “without merit” and seemed “designed to undermine the progressive work” of the organisation and damage its reputation.
In a statement, the organisation said child protection was a “priority” for its board. It rejected “in the strongest possible terms” the claim that a safeguarding issue had not been appropriately investigated, saying the allegation was “without foundation”. It said the issue arose prior to the two directors joining the board and “was dealt with fully at the time by the safeguarding department and the board”.
Scouting Ireland added that its finances were “healthy” and its accounts included a “contingency” to cover the cost of legal cases taken by abuse survivors.
The two board members prepared the briefing document for Sinn Féin, but it was later shared with the Department of Children, Scouting Ireland’s main public funder.
The briefing stated that Mr Reynolds was suspended as a board member and volunteer following a clash with Joe Marken, Scouting Ireland’s interim chief executive, during a board meeting last June.
The document was sent to the entire board on November 19th, at which point Mr Marken shared it with department officials, internal emails show. Mr Marken told the department one of the authors was suspended from the board, while the other was asked to leave a recent meeting “for a breach of the board’s code of conduct”.
A Scouting Ireland spokeswoman said it did not comment on disciplinary matters “in order to ensure due and fair process”. A department spokesman said officials were “reviewing” the allegations made by the two directors and had met Mr Reynolds and Mr Kinane last month.
Mr Reynolds said he could not comment on their claims or his suspension, while Mr Kinane did not respond to requests for comment.
Scouting Ireland, one of the largest youth organisations in the country, receives €1.3 million a year from the department. The funding was suspended in 2018 following controversy over the flawed handling of a serious sexual assault allegation concerning two adult volunteers. It was restored after its entire board was replaced as part of a governance overhaul.
During that controversy more than 350 people came forward to report being sexually abused as children in predecessor bodies, the Catholic Boy Scouts of Ireland and the Scout Association of Ireland. A 2020 report by child protection expert Ian Elliott concluded the past abuse was tolerated at the highest levels of the former bodies and covered up for decades.
- Sign up for push alerts and have the best news, analysis and comment delivered directly to your phone
- Find The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date
- Our In The News podcast is now published daily – Find the latest episode here
