Equality case rulings force Garda plan rethink

Plans for further the civilianisation of Garda clerical functions are to be reviewed after a tribunal found seven civilian employees…

Plans for further the civilianisation of Garda clerical functions are to be reviewed after a tribunal found seven civilian employees of the Garda are entitled to the same pay as trained gardai carrying out the same duties.

The Minster for Justice, Michael McDowell this morning said he was considering appealing the decision of the Equality Tribunal to the Labour Court after seven of 14 claimants had their compliant upheld.

"This is a complex case which raises important legal and other issues that need to be fully explored. I am seeking legal advice and once I have received that advice, I will consider the options at my disposal," Mr McDowell said.

The Minister has until January 3 rdnext year to lodge an appeal with the Labour Court.

READ MORE

He said the decision of the tribunal could have implications for his plans to increase Garda numbers.

"I want those Gardaí deployed to frontline policing duties and I want to proceed with the civilianisation of clerical work in An Garda Síochána. I am examining the implications of this decision, if it were to stand, for that programme of civilianisation."

The tribunal rulings related to two sets of claims, eight made in July of 2000 and another six in July of 2005. All involved women.

Seven of the claims dating back to 2000 were upheld on gender discrimination grounds. An eighth was found not to be covered by the Act.

Claims by six women initiated in 2005 were not upheld as the officer found they were not performing 'like work' to their male Garda colleagues.