Sir, – The Constitutional Convention meets today and tomorrow to discuss social economic and cultural rights in the Constitution. In 1937 the idea that people had economic, social and cultural (ESC) rights, as we now call them, was well ahead of its time.
Is is hardly surprising therefore that basic social and economic rights are expressed as being directive as opposed binding on legislature. Article 45 starts by stating the principles of social policy in the article are intended to be of “general guidance” to the Oireachtas. Financial constraints played a part in ensuring these principles of social policy were non-binding.
What is surprising is that the right to a home or suitable accommodation is not mentioned in the principles of social policy. It cannot be that housing conditions in 1930s were that far beneath the radar.
Given the current crisis in housing, and the likelihood that it is going to get worse, I hope that the members of the Constitutional Convention see the merit of including in the Constitution a right to a home or suitable accommodation as a fundamental right, not just one which is of general guidance to the Oireachtas.
If the members of the Convention have any doubts about the need for a specific right to housing, which is binding on the legislature, I suggest they read Fr Peter McVerry's very informative letter "Lack of help for the homeless" (February 21st). We have to give people in housing need more than just a sleeping bag.
MICHAEL MULLOOLY,
Ashdale Road,
Terenure, Dublin 6W.