Madam, - Regarding the ongoing discoveries I wish to emphasise that the portion of the Tara archaeological and historical complex, between Ross Cross and Garlow Cross (the Gabhra Valley), consists not just of one site but of a series of monuments. These constitute an integral part of the Tara landscape and amongst other things provide positive evidence for the earliest settlement in Co Meath, going back to close to 10,000 BC with the presence of settlement continuing (with some gaps) down to recent times. This provides an extraordinary record of human activity.
Contrary to some descriptions these are not fragile features but the remains of a variety of structures and finds, the normal evidence that is found on achaeological sites. Furthermore, these monuments should not be looked at in isolation but as an integral part of a rich cultural landscape. As a result, such discoveries confirm what many archaeologists had anticipated but their presence exceeds all expectations and strengthens the case for rerouting the M3 away from the Tara area.
I note from media reports that the relevant Minister is seeking advice regarding the issue but the organisations mentioned are State bodies that may not be in a position to put forward independent views.
The Tara discoveries are an integral part of our common heritage of which we are all stakeholders; therefore, they belong to all of us.
In order to critically evaluate the issue I recommend that a non-State body be established to review and consider the archaeological and historical issues emanating from the work already carried out. Such a body should be broadly based and include personnel from Government Departments as well as individuals and representatives of non-governmental agencies. A critical component has to consist of distinguished and experienced scholars from outside the country. I therefore trust that some organisation or group, such as An Taisce, would initiate such a body as a matter of urgency. - Yours, etc,
GEORGE EOGAN,
Rathgar,
Dublin 6