And another loss for England at Twickenham despite impressing at times

Listen | 35:50
Ireland's Andrew Porter and Argentina's Joel Sclavi clash. Photograph: Billy Stickland/©INPHO
Ireland's Andrew Porter and Argentina's Joel Sclavi clash. Photograph: Billy Stickland/©INPHO

Ireland won ugly against Argentina while England once again produced an at times scintillating performance, only to lose to South Africa. Whose camp would you rather be in?

Host Nathan Johns argues that England’s superior attacking game means it’s more likely everything else will click in time, while former Ireland international Gordon D’Arcy prefers to be developing a winning habit, even if it isn’t pretty.

Who is right will become evident during next year’s Six Nations. For now, Nathan, Gordon and John O’Sullivan pick through Ireland’s win over Felipe Contepomi’s Argentina. Why is the formerly potent attack stalling? Are the forwards providing enough ballast? What to make of the ongoing outhalf merry-go-round? Will widespread changes be made for the visit of Fiji?

Produced by John Casey.