There was no 11th-hour reprieve for London Irish. The mooted takeover by the American NUE Equity-led consortium failed to materialise, a dalliance that dates back seven months. Mick Crossan, who has owned London Irish since 2013 and has been actively seeking a buyer for the last few years, declined to financially underwrite next season’s Gallagher Premiership campaign.
The English RFU initially granted a seven-day stay of execution last week in the hope that a solution to the impasse might be found, but Tuesday’s curfew came and went, sounding the death knell, as London Irish followed Worcester Warriors and Wasps into a financial abyss, or suspension from the league to use the technical shorthand. Three Premiership clubs have gone to the wall in the last nine months, albeit for appreciably different reasons.
London Irish were roughly £30 million (€34.9 million) in debt, which, anecdotally, Crossan was prepared to write off if a buyer was prepared to pick up annual losses. Figures of between £4 million to £6 million have been suggested.
It’s less than a decade since Irish’s highest paid player would have been earning in the region of £250,000 a season, and in 2019-2020 the Wallaby secondrow Adam Coleman’s widely publicised £900,000 salary attested to a club whose top-end wage structure took out a hefty whack of their income stream.
The Counter Ruck: the rugby newsletter from The Irish Times
Rugby’s global rebel league plans fail to understand the heart of the sport
Thomas Clarkson ‘can’t help but feel happy’ after memorable Ireland debut against Argentina
Owen Doyle: Caelan Doris plays a risky game but match officials found wanting
Crossan, in an open letter on the club’s website, expressed his frustration and offered some context from his perspective. “Over the last seven months, I have been working closely with the RFU, PRL and representatives of NUE Equity to complete a widely publicised deal to acquire the club.
“Negotiations have been complex from the start, further complicated by issues regarding our tenancy at Brentford’s stadium and unrealistic demands from the governing body. But throughout, I have remained confident a deal could be made that would secure the long-term future of London Irish.
“As we neared the completion of the deal, I continually received promises, from both NUE Equity and Redstrike, that the acquisition would be completed imminently, and that funds would arrive within days.
“Right up to yesterday’s final deadline, we continued to receive verbal assurances from the group. I have trusted that these were not hollow promises and agreed to financially support the club throughout to ensure it could finish the season and give the group time to conclude the deal.
“Sadly, the promises have failed to materialise, and, despite our very best efforts, it was not possible to meet the conditions set by the RFU Club Financial Viability Group. Its subsequent disappointing decision to force our suspension has proved the tipping point where we will not be able to meet our current and future financial obligations.
“And after assessing our options last night, we agreed that administration offered the safest path forward for the club.”
That seven-day grace period was facilitated by the London Irish players, coaches and staff, agreeing to be paid 50 per cent of their wages for the month of May. It’s the human face of this desperately sad news that is most galling and warrants sympathy.
Director of Rugby Declan Kidney and head coach Les Kiss had done a brilliant job in steering London Irish to fifth place in this season’s Premiership and while several marquee players will be attractive to other clubs, most will struggle to find new employment as rosters have already been filled for next season.
Walking into another club for most players, coaches and staff isn’t a feasible goal. The players’ market was already saturated after Worcester and Wasps went to the wall and because of the shrinking size of squads.
Salaries in the English Championship aren’t in the same postcode as the Premiership and even though slightly better in ProD2 in France, few if any clubs will have slots available. The rise in the Gallagher Premiership salary cap from £5 million to £6.4 million does not kick in until the 2024-2025 season.
London Irish, in its 125th year, have also been served with a winding-up petition by HM Revenue and Customs for unpaid tax, which at face value might have had ramifications for the amateur arm of the club, which governs underage rugby as well as the senior men’s and women’s amateur game.
The amateur club has a 15-year lease to use their professional siblings state-of-the-art Hazelwood Complex, but the land is owned by London Irish Holdings, who were one of the companies named in the winding-up petition served to the club’s officials last week by the revenue commissioners.
Crossan wrote: “This development does not affect London Irish Amateur Rugby Football Club, to whom we recently granted a long lease on the Hazelwood premises and playing fields, or the operation of the Hazelwood facility whose facilities are extensively used for the benefit of all types of sporting activities and for the wider benefit of the local community.
One aspect of the club’s demise that has received less attention is that London Irish’s Academy, funded by the RFU, was arguably the best in England, producing a steady stream of players that went on to be capped at underage and senior level.
The professional club enjoyed a standing and loyalty in London’s Irish community, but it had long ceased to provide any players for Ireland, senior and underage, or the provincial teams, while the flow of players in the other direction, to London, had become a trickle. It was Irish in name but English in pathway terms. That matters little, though, when weighing up the implications for the people displaced by the latest events.
Mick Crossan’s open letter in full
I am extremely disappointed that the RFU elected to suspend London Irish from the Gallagher Premiership.
As a lifelong fan of London Irish, the club’s suspension is bitterly disappointing, and I understand the sadness felt by the thousands of our loyal supporters and the frustrations of our incredible coaches, medical staff, back-office team, and players. But this decision has ultimately ended any hope of an acquisition of the club and has regrettably forced us to file for administration.
Over the last seven months, I have been working closely with the RFU, PRL and representatives of NUE Equity to complete a widely publicised deal to acquire the club. Negotiations have been complex from the start, further complicated by issues regarding our tenancy at Brentford’s stadium and unrealistic demands from the governing body. But throughout, I have remained confident a deal could be made that would secure the long-term future of London Irish.
As we neared the completion of the deal, I continually received promises, from both NUE Equity and Redstrike, that the acquisition would be completed imminently, and that funds would arrive within days. Right up to yesterday’s final deadline, we continued to receive verbal assurances from the group. I have trusted that these were not hollow promises and agreed to financially support the club throughout to ensure it could finish the season and give the group time to conclude the deal.
Sadly, the promises have failed to materialise, and, despite our very best efforts, it was not possible to meet the conditions set by the RFU Club Financial Viability Group yesterday afternoon. Its subsequent disappointing decision to force our suspension has proved the tipping point where we will not be able to meet our current and future financial obligations. And after assessing our options last night, we agreed that administration offered the safest path forward for the club.
Since acquiring London Irish in 2013, I have made a significant financial investment to ensure we could compete at the highest level once again. We have worked tirelessly over the last few years to develop a more sustainable business model, trying to tap into the Irish community, developing new revenue streams, investing in our fantastic academy to develop future stars, and of course bringing the club back to its spiritual home in West London after 20 years away.
However, the reality is that professional rugby in this country is going through a hugely challenging time and, as we know, many clubs are sadly still struggling to get back on a stable path following the pandemic. I have publicly stated, on numerous occasions, that I would be willing to pass on the stewardship of the club if we could find the right person or group to take it forward and secure its long-term future. After a decade of supporting the club financially, it is not feasible for me to continue absorbing the multi-million-pound losses of the club each year, indefinitely.
The comments from the RFU Chair, Tom Ilube, last night completely overlook the precarious situation other clubs are currently in. Collectively, owners of clubs are working very hard to transform their models, but the lack of real support, at times, is non-existent. And it speaks volumes that Ralph Rimmer and Chris Pilling have been appointed by the Government as independent advisers to work on the future stability of rugby union in the UK.
The professional game in this country needs to be radically transformed. And the current leadership must urgently review its practices from top to bottom if it has a desire to see professional rugby continue in England.
Administration has always been the last resort, and something we hoped we could avoid. And we bitterly regret the difficulties it will present.
My focus is now on working with the appointed administrator and I hope that the club will come out of administration as quickly as possible. This development does not affect London Irish Amateur Rugby Football Club, to whom we recently granted a long lease on the Hazelwood premises and playing fields, or the operation of the Hazelwood facility whose facilities are extensively used for the benefit of all types of sporting activities and for the wider benefit of the local community.
Finally, I would like to take this opportunity to thank everyone for the support you have shown the club over the years. I share your sadness and frustration at today’s news, and I very much hope the administrators can find a way forward for London Irish Rugby Club.
