Soccer

Cas dismisses Russia appeal against Fifa and Uefa bans

Appeals from Football Union of Russia and four clubs in the country dismissed by Court of Arbitration for Sport

An appeal against the exclusion of Russian national teams and clubs from world and European competition has been dismissed by the Court of Arbitration for Sport. Photograph: Andrew Milligan/PA
An appeal against the exclusion of Russian national teams and clubs from world and European competition has been dismissed by the Court of Arbitration for Sport. Photograph: Andrew Milligan/PA
Fri Jul 15 2022 - 13:42

An appeal against the exclusion of Russian national teams and clubs from world and European competition has been dismissed by the Court of Arbitration for Sport.

Uefa and Fifa imposed a ban on Russian participation in their tournaments on February 28th, days after Russia launched its invasion of Ukraine.

The Football Union of Russia (Fur) and a group of Russian clubs appealed to Cas against the ban, but Cas announced on Friday that those appeals had all been dismissed.

[ No welcome for Russian tennis player in Dublin ]

Six appeals were lodged in all – one by the Fur against Fifa and one by the Fur against Uefa, and one each from four clubs against Uefa – Zenit St Petersburg, FC Sochi, CSKA Moscow and Dynamo Moscow.

READ MORE

All were dismissed by a Cas panel which heard them via video conference on July 5th and 11th.

A Cas statement explaining the dismissal said: “The panel determined that the escalation of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine, and the public and government responses worldwide, created unforeseen and unprecedented circumstances to which Fifa and Uefa had to respond.

“In determining that Russian teams and clubs should not participate in competitions under their aegis while such circumstances persisted, the panel held that both parties acted within the scope of the discretion granted to them under their respective statutes and regulations.”

The statement continued: “The panel found it unnecessary to characterise the nature of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine, but only to focus on the consequences of such conflict for the competitions affected.

[ Fifa and Uefa suspend Russian teams from international and club game ]

“The panel finds it unfortunate that the current military operations in Ukraine, for which Russian football teams, clubs, and players have themselves no responsibility, had, by reason of the decisions of Fifa and Uefa, such an adverse effect on them and Russian football generally, but those effects were, in the panel’s view, offset by the need for the secure and orderly conduct of football events for the rest of the world.”

The joint decision by Fifa and Uefa to suspend on February 28th came hours after the International Olympic Committee (IOC) executive board had issued a recommendation that international sports federations should not invite or allow the participation of Russian or Belarusian athletes in their events amid the invasion.

The ban meant Russia were unable to enter the play-offs for qualification for the men’s World Cup in Qatar, or to compete in the ongoing women’s Euros. Portugal took Russia’s place in that event.

Belarusian national teams and clubs can still compete, but Uefa has insisted any home matches involving sides from that country must be played in a neutral territory and behind closed doors.

The Fur issued a statement in response to the decision.

“The Fur strongly disagrees with the Cas decision and reserves the right to continue protecting its own interests,” it read.

“The Fur is currently awaiting the arbitral awards, and the decision on further actions will be made after the analysis of the grounds for the Cas panel’s decisions.

“The options may include appeal to the Federal Supreme Court of Switzerland and filing claims to Cas related to compensation for financial losses incurred by the Fur as the result of Uefa and Fifa’s actions.”

Fifa and Uefa have also been approached for comment.