Alec Stewart admitted yesterday that his chances of success as England's new Test captain depended much on the man he has replaced in the unforgiving top job.

Mike Atherton's two-year slump in batting form threatens to undermine England in this summer's series against South Africa - especially as Stewart's elevation and a likely return to wicket-keeping duties will mean him giving up the role of opener.

Only last winter Stewart and Atherton were identified as England's main strength as an opening pair.

Stewart made all the right noises when his appointment was confirmed at Lord's yesterday and there can be no doubting his enthusiasm and total commitment to the cause.

Yet even his father, former England manager Micky Stewart, reacted to the news by saying that being Test captain "would not be all honey and roses".

Stewart takes over from Atherton with England's wait for a full series win over a major nation now standing at 11 years.

There is more than a whiff of stop gap necessity about Stewart's appointment - but at the same time it is eminently sensible with an Australian winter tour also fast approaching.

And England's lack of quality options right through the side was underlined when Stewart kicked off his reign yesterday by saying an Atherton return to batting form was vital, adding: "I will be very surprised if Mike is not playing in the first Test next month."